Best Games With New Game Plus: When the First Playthrough Was Just Practice

New Game Plus at its worst is just "the same game but enemies have more HP." At its best, it's a fundamentally different experience, new bosses, new story branches, new endings, and the satisfaction of destroying early-game challenges with your endgame build. Here are the games that get NG+ right.

Which games have New Game Plus that changes the game?

Chrono Trigger, NieR: Automata, Undertale, Dark Souls, and Elden Ring all feature NG+ modes that fundamentally transform the experience. These games add new endings, new perspectives, permanent consequences, or entirely different gameplay mechanics on subsequent playthroughs, making NG+ feel like a different game rather than a repeat.

Chrono Trigger, invented New Game Plus in 1995. Carry your endgame stats into a new playthrough and access 13 different endings based on when and how you defeat the final boss. Some endings are only accessible in NG+ because you need endgame power to reach Lavos at unusual story points. The definitive NG+ implementation.

NieR: Automata, the first playthrough is Route A. NG+ is Route B, the same events from a different character's perspective with entirely new gameplay mechanics (hacking minigames). Route C after that is an entirely new story. The "real" game starts after your first ending. You need three playthroughs for the complete experience.

Undertale, the Genocide and Pacifist routes function as NG+ experiences. The game remembers your choices across playthroughs and permanently alters itself based on your previous decisions. Completing Genocide changes the Pacifist ending permanently, even after resetting.

Dark Souls, NG+ increases enemy health and damage while letting you keep your gear. But the real NG+ draw is trying different builds, a sorcery run vs a pure melee run vs an SL1 challenge run creates genuinely different games.

Elden Ring, NG+ up to NG+7 with escalating difficulty. New builds become the replay motivation, if your first run was STR, NG+ as INT/sorcery is a different game. The elden ring best weapons and elden ring best builds posts help plan alternative builds.

Which games have NG+ with new content?

God of War Ragnarok, Resident Evil 4 Remake, Hades, and The Witcher 3 all reward NG+ players with exclusive gear, weapons, or story content unavailable in the first playthrough. These games make returning worthwhile by adding tangible new items and systems rather than just recycling existing content at higher difficulty.

God of War Ragnarok, NG+ adds new armor sets, upgraded versions of existing gear, and Spartan Rage variants. Some of the game's best equipment is NG+ exclusive.

Resident Evil 4 (Remake), NG+ unlocks the Chicago Sweeper (infinite ammo tommy gun) and other weapons that transform the gameplay from horror to power fantasy.

Hades, technically the entire game is NG+. Each escape attempt carries persistent narrative progress. The Heat system adds modular difficulty increases with specific rewards. You need many "playthroughs" to see the full story. The hades best builds post has more.

The Witcher 3, NG+ at higher difficulty with carry-over gear. Scaled enemies and the opportunity to make different story choices (romance a different partner, side with different factions).

Which games have the hardest New Game Plus?

Sekiro, Hollow Knight, and Baldur's Gate 3 offer NG+ experiences (or NG+ equivalents) focused on testing player mastery. Sekiro's charmless NG+7 with demon bell is considered one of the hardest challenges in all of gaming, while Hollow Knight's Steel Soul mode deletes your save on death.

Sekiro, each NG+ cycle removes the resurrection safety net (Kuro's charm) and adds a demon bell that increases difficulty further. NG+7 charmless with demon bell is one of the hardest challenges in gaming.

Hollow Knight, Steel Soul mode is permadeath NG+. One death and the save file is deleted. Every boss becomes a life-or-death encounter.

Baldur's Gate 3, while there's no traditional NG+, the respec system and 12 classes with multiclassing make fresh playthroughs feel like NG+. Different class choices create entirely different combat experiences and unlock unique dialogue options.

Which games are designed around New Game Plus?

Persona 5 Royal, Fire Emblem: Three Houses, and Starfield are all built with the expectation that players will start over at least once. These games gate meaningful content, story routes, or relationship progression behind repeat playthroughs, making NG+ part of the core design rather than an afterthought.

Some games are designed around multiple playthroughs:

Persona 5 Royal, NG+ carries social stats (Knowledge, Guts, etc.) making it easier to max all confidant relationships. The third semester content requires specific confidant progress, NG+ lets you reach it more easily.

Fire Emblem: Three Houses, three (effectively four) story routes. Each is a full playthrough with different characters, battles, and story. The game expects you to play at least twice.

Starfield, the main quest ending leads to a NG+ with a narrative twist. Bethesda designed the game around the assumption that you'd enter NG+, some content only exists there.

What makes New Game Plus worth it?

Good NG+ offers at least one of four things: new content (bosses, items, story), a new perspective (different character or abilities), a mastery challenge (harder difficulty with earned tools), or narrative justification (the story makes replaying meaningful). NG+ that only inflates enemy numbers is not worth the player's time.

From our development experience on Granny's Rampage, NG+ is worth building when it offers at least one of: new content (bosses, items, story), new perspective (different character or abilities), mastery challenge (harder difficulty with earned tools), or narrative justification (the story makes replaying meaningful).

NG+ that's just "same game, bigger numbers" isn't worth the player's time. The best NG+ implementations make you want to replay, not because they gate content, but because the new experience is genuinely compelling.

For more replayability content, the most replayable games, best short games, and best video game endings posts have more.

What are the best New Game Plus games overall?

The best NG+ games by category are Chrono Trigger for endings, NieR: Automata for story, Elden Ring and Dark Souls for build variety, Sekiro for mastery challenge, and Undertale for narrative consequences. The common thread is that great NG+ provides a genuinely new experience, not the same game with bigger numbers.

The rule: NG+ should offer a new experience, not the same experience with bigger numbers.